Skip to content
Close

LotDrop-Nav_Supplies

Forms & Supplies

LotDrop-Nav_Apparel

Corporate Apparel

LotDrop-Nav_Promo

Promotional Items

Line of new car vehicles in showroom
Hilary Holmes RheaumeNov 27, 2024 10:25:22 AM2 min read

Separate Agreements for Models in the Same Line Make

Imagine: You are a current franchised dealer, and your original equipment manufacturer (“OEM”) announces a new model within your franchised line make.  When you contact your dealer representative for information about ordering the model, you learn that you are not eligible to order it.  Rather, you are instructed to enter into a separate dealer agreement, at which time the OEM will determine whether you are eligible to sell the new model.  This violates the New Hampshire Bill of Rights.

New Hampshire law carefully regulates the relationship between automotive, equipment, and powersports manufacturers and dealers under the Dealer Bill of Rights (R.S.A. 357-C).  Importantly, the Dealer Bill of Rights prohibits manufacturers from requiring dealers to enter into separate dealer agreements to obtain a model within the same line make.

Specifically, the Dealer Bill of Rights provides that an OEM cannot:

Fail or refuse to sell or offer to sell to all motor vehicle franchisees of a line make, all models manufactured for that line make, or require[e] a dealer to pay any extra fee, [or] execut[e] a separate franchise agreement…”

A “line make” refers to the OEM’s brand of vehicles, encompassing all models and variants offered under that brand.  The Dealer Bill of Rights defines a “line make” as motor vehicles, equipment, and/or powersports equipment that are “offered for sale, lease, or distribution under a common name, trademark, service mark or brand name of the franchisor or manufacturer of the motor vehicle.”  In other words, a line make includes all cars, trucks, SUVs, and specialty vehicles under the brand name.

Under New Hampshire law, an OEM must allow a current franchised dealer to sell all models within the franchised line make.  The OEM cannot require a dealer to enter into a separate franchise agreement for each line make, nor can it require a dealer to pay an extra fee to be eligible to sell a model within the franchised line make.  To note, there are other prohibitions under the Dealer Bill of Rights that are not discussed here, such as an OEM cannot require a dealer to purchase unreasonable advertising displays or other materials before it can sell a model within a line make.

If you find yourself in a position where your OEM refuses to sell you a model within your franchised line make, just remember: this is prohibited under New Hampshire law, so contact your legal counsel immediately.

avatar

Hilary Holmes Rheaume

Hilary provides businesses of all sizes with thoughtful legal counsel, with a specialized focus in representing automotive and equipment dealers throughout New England. Hilary has an in-depth understanding of issues facing family-owned automotive and equipment dealerships, and is frequently asked to speak on related topics such as the New Hampshire Dealer Bill of Rights, privacy and data considerations, and employment-related issues for dealerships. Hilary represents dealers in franchise-related issues, and dealer/manufacturer relations, including issues involving add points, terminations, transfer of ownership, and relocations. She also represents dealers in regulatory and compliance matters, licensing, advertising, consumer issues, and commercial litigation. In addition to representing dealers in state and federal court, Hilary has experience representing clients before the Motor Vehicle Industry Board. Hilary also represents clients state agencies, including the Department of Labor and the New Hampshire Human Rights Commission, to name a few. Hilary has secured several victories for auto and equipment dealers and recently represented the New Hampshire Automobile Dealers Association in front of the New Hampshire Supreme Court concerning New Hampshire’s law on anti-assignment clauses for body shops. No matter the client or the industry, Hilary’s goals remain the same: to protect each client’s unique interests and move their business forward.

RELATED ARTICLES